Mint | Is Quietness the Most Elusive Luxury in India?

We have privileged vision over hearing, turning up the volume on everything from loudspeakers to construction noise. Peace and quiet must be available to every Indian instead of only those with soundproof homes and noise cancellation devices.

What might be the rarest luxury in India? Perhaps it is quietness.

When was the last time you were able to be in blissful silence? No matter where you travel in our country, you encounter human activity-related sounds. I have been deep inside forests where, along with the roar of a tiger or the tap-tap-tap of a woodpecker, I could hear airhorns from far away trucks, or the distant strains of amplified music.

During the recent Ganesha festival I was in Mumbai, enchanted by a beautiful pandal but distracted in my prayers by a deafening and distorted aarti broadcast over giant outward-facing loudspeakers. The attendant at the entrance shrugged and smiled when I blocked my ears with my fingers. I wondered if he had become immune to the noise.

Early humans relied on their finely tuned hearing to protect themselves from threat, and to anticipate and respond to danger. There are still people who live close to nature, who can hear the background music of the universe. I have been with birders who can hear the smallest sound of a warbler or an owl from several metres away. I have walked with naturalists from ancient traditions who can hear the wind move over blades of grass. Most urbanites like me simply cannot tune in to those frequencies anymore. Over time we have privileged vision over hearing. We may have lost the ability to hear subtle sounds and to listen to what the silence has to share.

Diwali used to be a festival of lights, but now risks becoming a festival of noise. Bombs and ladis, which are the noisiest of firecrackers, make up more than 60% of Sivakasi’s annual production. Earlier, firecrackers were restricted to Diwali, New Year’s Eve, and political victory marches. Now they are part of every celebration in a country with maybe hundreds of festivals across communities and religions, with continuous elections, and an increasing number of sports events.

It is not just celebration that creates noise pollution in India. Street traffic is a big contributor, with Indians’ penchant for honking driving decibels up further. Airplanes, trains, industrial activity, generators, and construction sites are notorious for the noise they emit. Our metropolitan areas have ambient noise levels that are way above safe limits.

A 2017 study by the National Physical Laboratory, Central Pollution Control Board, and Delhi Technological University found that in seven monitored cities, fewer than 10 of the 70 sites studied met the noise standards. Importantly, not one commercial or residential site complied. Despite being bombarded night and day, not many people voice their concerns about this issue. In India, often, pain does not easily reveal itself; it has to be uncovered.

DISRUPTIONS AND DAMAGE

Two theories about the word noise say it may come from the Latin word ‘noxia’ meaning injury or hurt, or from ‘nausea’. Both origins describe unhealthy states. The World Health Organization (WHO) categorizes noise levels above 65 decibels (dB) as pollution, and above 75dB as harmful. Our government sets a level of 145dB for firecrackers as anything higher may cause acute cochlear damage. Yet some firecrackers below that safety range can generate enough noise to cause sudden, permanent hearing loss.

Any chronic or intrusive noise can act as a stressor on the body. Long-term exposure is associated with hypertension, ischemic heart disease, and stroke. Even if people believe they have become used to noise, the body still registers the stress activation through raised cortisol and adrenaline levels and increased blood pressure and heart rate.

Sleep disruption is another significant outcome of noise pollution. Even short-term sleep deficiency can have knock-on impacts, and chronic sleep deprivation has wide health consequences, such as higher cardiometabolic risk. WHO recommends less than 30 A-weighted decibels in bedrooms during the night for a good-quality sleep. Not many spaces where Indians sleep would meet that goal.

A couple of years ago the local airport near my neighbourhood in Bengaluru had given permission for commercial airlines to train pilots at all hours of the night. The planes flew so low over our densely populated community that I felt I could jump up and touch them. The sound was so deafening and unpredictable that many of us could not sleep soundly for weeks. With the ensuing daytime fatigue and poorer performance, we joked that India’s GDP might be affected since so many entrepreneurs come from this locality. It took a concerted campaign across communities and classes to halt an activity that should not have been allowed in the first place.

EARLY SIGNS

A big concern is the link with children’s cognitive development. Chronic exposure to noise near schools or homes is associated with poorer reading comprehension, memory, and attention. ‘Stop. I can’t hear myself think’ may not be as exaggerated a statement as we thought.

Other vulnerable groups are the elderly, especially those with pre-existing heart conditions, and industrial and construction workers who are exposed to more than desirable noise over an 8-hour day. And think of all the traffic personnel, the transport workers, the security staff, the roadside vendors, the gig workers who work all the time in acoustically punishing conditions.

A new and disturbing phenomenon is the increase in youngsters habituated to loud music on their earphones. A WHO-led review published in BMJ Global Health pooled 33 studies from the past two decades, and the authors estimated that globally one billion young people could be at risk from unsafe listening practices. A small cross-sectional study of 350 people aged 18-25 at a Puducherry tertiary hospital concluded that prolonged use of ear devices over time might be significantly associated with early noise-induced hearing loss.

In a civilisation so finely attuned over centuries to practising and valuing meditation and maun (silence), how did we get to this point? Why are we unable to recognise our distress?

Since noise pollution is rather low on the nation’s radar, it is not surprising that there are but a handful of non-profit organizations working on this. Among them are Awaaz Foundation and Quiet India. Both conduct innovative campaigns to raise awareness and create impact. Apart from a citizens’ pledge to reduce noise, Quiet India has piloted noise ratings on Google restaurant reviews, to sensitize customers. Awaaz participated in a public interest litigation (PIL) for the implementation of Silence Zone regulations and stricter enforcement parameters for firecrackers and loudspeakers in Maharashtra.

Local groups also band together against noise. Loud parties and late-night music at the resorts around Corbett National Park helped launch a Kumaon chapter of Uttarakhand Against Noise Pollution. In Bengaluru and other cities, there are sporadic ‘No Honking’ campaigns.

The Mumbai traffic police tried an interesting experiment in 2020 before the pandemic hit. It was called ‘the punishing signal’ and if noise levels from honking crossed 85dB, the signal would reset to red. ‘Honk more, wait more’ was the viral video campaign. By its own analysis there was a 32% drop in average decibel readings. Yet this campaign has not scaled. We will need many more experiments with behavioural nudges to change mindsets.

India has strict laws under the Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000, which classify cities into four distinct zones which have separate permissible noise limits for day and night. In residential areas, the limit is 55db in the day and 45dB at night, while noise in commercial areas is capped at 65/55dB. For industrial areas, it is 75dB by day and 70 at night.

The courts have also stepped in vigorously against public noise. The Supreme Court of India has declared that the right to life under Article 21 includes the right to a peaceful environment. It has codified a 10pm to 6am ban on loudspeakers and outdoor firecrackers. Separately, in 2000, the court ruled that religious practices must yield to noise control laws, which are aimed at protecting public health. State governments have the legal authority to extend loudspeaker curfews until midnight for cultural or religious festivals, though it is meant to be capped at a maximum of 15 days in a calendar year. We only have to step out and listen to know that these laws are largely breached.

Who’s keeping track? Far from reducing the noise, we now have enthusiastic, competing sounds from mosques, churches, and temples. Until the larger public becomes much more aware of the hazards from noise pollution and understands the importance of respecting acoustic boundaries, the state alone cannot enforce a social good.

Collective celebration, inevitably accompanied by loud music or cheering, develops social capital and camaraderie. In fact, some people find the quiet unnerving. It makes them feel lonely. Those who live alone often leave the TV on to feel as if they have company. Yet there is a difference between sound and noise pollution. Noise pollution is defined as unwanted, excessive, or disturbing sound that poses a threat to the health and well-being of humans and wildlife.

Outside my home in Bengaluru is a public park. Hundreds of youths enjoy playing games there all day and sometimes into the night. They can be very loud, but there is no amplification. Somehow it does not disturb me enough to count as noise pollution. Why can we not celebrate our festivals, our religious rituals and public events similarly without loudspeakers?

It is time to enforce all our protective laws and create a true public movement for a quieter India. Peace and quiet must become a luxury that every Indian can afford, instead of only those with soundproof homes and noise cancellation devices. Let’s democratize the joy of silence.

DROWNING OUT WILDLIFE

Human-made noise can disrupt the communication, navigation, foraging and reproduction of both terrestrial and marine creatures. Take birds, for example. Bird calls are the most sophisticated forms of sound-based communication in the natural world. Researchers have found that birds in noisy environments consistently produced calls with significantly higher peak frequencies than those in quieter habitats, which interferes with mating success.

The Himalayan monal, the state bird of Uttarakhand, which is a stand-in metric for the fragility of the Himalayan ecosystem, is changing its call and song because of human activity. “In listening to the monal we hear the Himalayas asking for space, silence, and care,” says Anjal Prakash, a researcher.

Large terrestrial animals like elephants are equally affected. They communicate using frequencies between 14 and 35 Hz, which can be drowned out by even far-off traffic noise. India’s beloved tigers don’t like the noise either. There is recent evidence that high-traffic roads affect tiger movement and population connectivity across tiger reserves.

The story is the same when it comes to marine life. Shipping, traffic, and industrial activity have reduced the acoustic space of whales and dolphins by up to 90%. High-intensity naval sonar and seismic testing and deep-sea mining activities disorient marine mammals and are linked to mass whale strandings. Compared to pre-industrial ocean background noise, which was around 80dB on average, levels can go as high as 120dB, louder than a rock concert.

No wonder marine mammals have difficulty hearing and responding to each other. Even tiny insects can be severely impacted. Insect pollinators like bees are critical to keeping natural ecosystems in balance. They rely on subtle vibrations to detect pollen, and noise pollution can interfere with their navigation and reduce pollination efficiency. The noise we make is hurting all other living systems.

Shipping companies are coordinating to reduce ships’ speeds to cut underwater noise. National parks in the west are introducing quiet zones and reduced speed limits, documenting a quick return of noise-sensitive species. In Stuttgart, Germany, green corridors, which are connected strips of parks and gardens, both absorb urban noise and provide safe passage for urban wildlife. In London they are experimenting with acoustic shields against traffic noise. Much more innovation is on the way.

In India there is still a wide gap in noise pollution research, most of which is centred around the negative impact on humans. Private philanthropy and the state need to step in to bridge this deficit. If we rejig our conservation priorities to mitigate noise pollution, we can have a significant impact across natural ecosystems that sustain us.

First Published in The LiveMint 

IE | The Silence of Adolescent Boys and its Costs

by Natasha Joshi & Luis Miranda 

Vulnerability in adolescent boys is not a subject that is often discussed, but one that has huge societal consequences – for both young men and women. One of us, Natasha, leads the gender portfolio at Rohini Nilekani Philanthropies (RNP), and repeatedly found that boys are conditioned from a young age to keep their mouths shut when it comes to feelings. A group of researchers commissioned by RNP spoke with more than 80 Indian young males – aged between 18 and 24 and belonging to different social classes – about what their lives were like. Expectedly, a lot was said about the need to earn and provide for the family. But as the conversations progressed, a nuanced image of adolescent boyhood appeared – one with many unspoken challenges.

Childhood was universally described as a cherished phase, a time when boys can cry, be afraid, and be “free”. But adolescence is a remarkable shift. Having a group of friends is survival for boys, yet sizing up and teasing was reported as the most unpleasant part of being in a group. Adolescent boys get picked on for their looks, their genitals, the pitch of their voice, or their physical prowess. Yet, they can’t complain as that makes one an even bigger target. When these early lessons teach boys that expressing distress or asking for help is bad, it’s no surprise that we end up in a society where men see seeking help as a sign of weakness.

The other emotional upheaval adolescent boys never talk about is breakups. The rising instances of revenge porn – where jilted (male) lovers publicly release intimate or morphed pictures of their exes – is an example of how hurt, shame, hormones and social norms are combining to produce novel anti-social behaviours in males like sextortion, doxxing, trolling and much more.

CBSE’s cyber safety manual tackles the complicated subject of revenge porn tersely, with ONLY a parting shot, “youngsters must learn to cope with rejection as it is a part of life but not the end of the world”. This is hardly adequate as it takes no cognisance of the fact that teenagers are wired to seek the approval of their peers, and telling one person to regulate themselves is not the solution; group norms need to be looked at.

Luis has observed, as a mentor at Take Charge, a programme, he co-founded to mentor Catholic youth in Mumbai, that group discussions focus on skills or mindsets, but they never go into sexuality or relationships. His wife, Dr Fiona Dias Miranda, who has been working for over 20 years with adolescents on human sexual development, agrees by saying that schools educate young males about the physiological changes taking place in their bodies, but conversations on sexuality, safe sex, consent, respect, and the emotional aspect of relationships are never addressed.

Luis too learned this the hard way. Around 55 years ago, in Madras, a butler working for a family took hold of the family’s only son, undressed and lay on top of the child. The boy never told anyone at the time, and even years later, except confiding in his wife. That is until a friend asked him if he would do a piece with her on the lives of adolescent boys and men in India, and Luis decided it was time. It hit him that he also was a victim of abuse, and while he has never felt like a victim, he’s kept quiet about this for years. Working on this piece prompted Luis to talk about this topic with one of the young men he has known for many years, but only now discussed sexual abuse with. Hours later, Luis received a message from the young man at 2 am saying he might have something to share too.

This lack of societal understanding of young men’s adolescent vulnerability is getting amplified by growing macroeconomic trends such as lack of high-school education resulting in a workforce that increasingly lacks emotional, social and academic literacy. According to a 2024 NITI Aayog report, there are more girls in secondary school than boys. The pressure to earn, along with the rise in gig work, is pushing adolescent boys to drop out and enter employment early. Once there, they face heightened risks of violence, substance abuse, and crime. Ultimately, it is society that bears the cost of leaving thousands of men, undereducated and emotionally repressed.

The central question to ask: If adolescent boys need help, can we imagine public initiatives that support their unique needs? Can we, as Richard Reeves says, stop seeing “the problem of boys as the problem with boys”?

First Published In The Indian Express

ET | Be mindful, listen, empathise: Is modern life killing our mental health? New findings reveal alarming truths about social isolation

Synopsis: World Mental Health Day highlights the significance of listening to people with lived experiences of mental health conditions. These experiences can help shape mental health services and combat stigma. A focus on social connections is vital for improving overall mental wellness in society. While mental illness requires specialized care, many can benefit from increased social bonds. Emphasizing compassion and cooperation may strengthen community resilience against modern challenges.

The theme for this year’s World Mental Health Day is ‘Lived experiences heard: Real voices, real change’. It provides an opportunity to meaningfully engage with people with lived experience (PWLE) of mental health conditions, and to recognise their knowledge as a vital form of expertise.

It means creating opportunities for PWLEs to influence decisions, co-design services, strengthen peer-led approaches, challenge stigma and strengthen accountability. It’s also an opportunity to understand underlying societal conditions that might endanger mental well-being.

Alienation and isolation are the twin themes of this decade. Despite the many ways we have to connect online and offline, people feel cut off, and lonely. Our social selves seem to have shrunk. We have become the anxious generation(s).

Yet, our biology equips us to be social, to live in groups, to cooperate. Economist-epidemiologist Ramanan Laxminarayan argues in his new book, Bacteria to Buddha: How Cooperation Shaped Consciousness – and Makes Us Human, that consciousness evolved not in isolated individual minds, but as machinery to keep complex social relationships stable. Historian Rutger Bregman, in his 2019 book, Humankind: A Hopeful History, describes humanity’s evolutionary superpower as empathy, and collective cooperation.

If we are so wired for connection, what is interfering with that today?

First, let’s separate mental illness from mental health. Mental illness is real to some people and requires qualified attention and support. Mental wellness is for everyone. Like our bodies, our minds need the right nutrients and exercise to keep them balanced. Our brains, designed by evolutionary biology, thrive on face-to-face community interaction. Our neurochemistry is wired to build trust, repair conflict and maintain relationships.

In the last 30 years, we have moved from face-to-face interaction to screen-to-screen interface. We can engage with dozens of people a day without ever meeting them. As Laxminarayan says, we can now live and die surrounded by services, untouched by community.

Neuroscientists remind us that our brain circuits evolved to coordinate living in groups and can atrophy from under-stimulation. But these are the same systems that regulate stress and stability. Lack of social connection reduces oxytocin, raises cortisol, and breeds anxiety and mistrust.

This might well be why many more people – especially post-pandemic – are reporting an increase in common mental disorders. According to a 2015–16 National Mental Health Survey, approximately 5% of Indians (about 75 million) experience depression, anxiety and stress, which are termed as ‘common mental disorders’. Their higher prevalence in urban metros underscores how modern living strains human psychological resilience.

But we can rebuild our mental elasticity. While people with mental illness require specialised care, millions experiencing the loneliness or stress of modern life can be helped. Last year at Manotsava, the National Mental Health Festival in Bengaluru, psychologist Richie Davidson presented powerful research to show that practising mindfulness and compassion acts as mental strength training, and fundamentally alters the brain to make kindness and connection a default mode of operation. This connection may be as important to health as food or sleep.

Restoring social bonds and creating enabling conditions for connection is a powerful intervention by itself. Swami Satchidananda got it right when he said, ‘Replace “I” with “we”, and “illness” becomes “wellness”.’ Without that, we may fritter away our greatest evolutionary gifts of compassion and collaboration.

Society is the ultimate creative force to solve emerging societal problems. Today, AI’s expanding influence in our personal lives surfaces new questions. Will we be able to retain and strengthen human capacities that machines may not be able to easily acquire? If we understand that our comparative advantage is in compassion, cooperation and caring, we might exercise that societal muscle more deliberately.

First Published in The Economic Times 

SSIR | Our Vanishing Developmental Commons

Written by Tanya Kak

When I was a child, like many children, the street was where I learned how to live in the world. Playing was not just playing. We gathered every evening, first to decide what to play, then making our way through intense debates about how: the rules to follow, the boundary conditions to honor, the alliances that would dictate team formation, and heated discussions over strategies to win. In that one hour, we practiced negotiating, disagreeing, and finding a middle ground. We learned how power shifted, all while retaining our sense of play and wonder. In this shifting social drama, everyone was simultaneously an actor, an audience, a rule-maker, and a student.

When was the last time you saw children playing on the streets? When was the last time this was how you learned?

Today, for children and adults alike, learning can often begin somewhere very different: in search bars, recommendation feeds, and AI-generated summaries. But while conversations about artificial intelligence increasingly revolve around productivity and efficiency, what is lost when the environments that once cultivated social and embodied learning get replaced by systems optimized for speed, convenience, and certainty? Who do we become when our theaters of social learning are outsourced, and when imagination is supplied on demand instead of cultivated through practice? How do these new technological changes reshape the conditions through which people learn, connect, and participate in the world? How do they make meaning of the various social developments happening around them? Are there capacities and skills that must stay stubbornly human even when AI can automate them and do them more efficiently?

Finally: What might this mean for a social sector whose work depends upon precisely these capacities?

For much of human history, what can be called the “developmental commons” were the streets, forests, playgrounds, libraries, and classrooms, shared social spaces where attention was exercised, imagination was stretched, relationships were formed, and, most importantly, knowledge was situated within lived experience. Today, as digital platforms are becoming some of the primary environments in which young people (and many others) learn to relate to themselves and others, we need to explore how the environments in which we spend our time shape the capacities we develop. A growing body of research shows that cognition does not occur solely within the brain, but emerges through interactions with bodies, physical environments, movement, objects, and other people. More than just receiving information, learning is also about the conditions in which knowledge is encountered and made meaningful.

So: What kind of world of learning are we creating?

1. A frictionless world has a cost.

In conservation and environment-related work, restoring the connection between humans and nature is central to a people- and planet-friendly society. Much depends on encountering the living world directly, exploring the wild, and holding its many contradictions and uncertainties. Sometimes this means rigorous scientific observations; other times, using anecdotal insights to bridge the gap between knowledge and practice. In both cases, it means experiencing friction as a feature through real-world engagement.

Can technology deepen connection with nature without becoming a substitute for it, or do we lose our sense of play and wonder when learning becomes frictionless?

Nature is part of the cognitive environment through which learning happens, not outside of it. And this insight has important implications for how we think about technology in the social sector. A community practitioner reviewing an AI-generated summary may gain access to information, but a practitioner spending time in a village, listening to stories and observing relationships, develops contextual judgement and holds local nuance that grounds that information. In many cases, the process through which knowledge is acquired is inseparable from the quality of the knowledge itself.

The challenge, therefore, is how technology can be designed and deployed in ways that strengthen, rather than displace, embodied forms of learning and engagement. Even when technology can create efficiencies and quick wins, sometimes choosing not to use it can help retain productive friction and be the more helpful choice.

For example, the Nature Conservation Foundation programs connecting people to birds have expanded from field-based learning and printed resources to include online courses, digital platforms, and tools that make bird identification more accessible to the public. These efforts have broadened participation significantly, but NCF remains guided by a simple principle: The value of technology lies in its ability to draw people back into a relationship with the natural world. There are innovations that have been able to do this successfully: Tools like Merlin, an AI-powered bird identification app developed by the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, demonstrate a different possibility for technology. But the key is that rather than replacing the experience of being outdoors, Merlin helps people identify birds they see or hear in real time, turning a moment of curiosity into a deeper encounter with the natural world.

2. AI slop is an attention problem before it is an information problem.

We are entering an era where information can be generated faster than it can be verified or meaningfully interpreted. This information abundance obviously magnifies challenges around misinformation, but also around how our attention can be used as a currency. And while the distortion of facts is an important challenge, we also need to look at which facts are being made visible to begin with.

Cognitive neuroscientist Maryanne Wolf argues that the shift toward digitally mediated reading environments may be reshaping cognitive processes associated with what she calls “deep reading,” typically associated with the capacity for reflection, for cultivating empathy and critical analysis, and for encouraging inference and imaginative engagement. As information arrives in rapid, broken streams, attention itself becomes fragmented. The consequence is a diminished capacity to stay with complexity long enough for understanding to emerge.

We see the consequences of this shift emerging in different forms. Organizations working on gender equity are dealing with the growing influence of the manosphere, a loose ecosystem of influencers and online communities that rigidly frame masculinity and often promote hostile ideas about it. Generative AI and recommendation systems can accelerate the spread of such narratives, creating feedback loops in which misinformation and polarization travel faster than nuance and dialogue.

A different but equally significant concern is invisibility. Large language models learn from what is documented, digitized, and visible online, focusing on places that receive extensive media coverage, have well-documented institutional histories, and digital footprints. Information on smaller cities, local citizen movements, oral histories, and everyday governance realities often remain underrepresented. This representation inequality makes entire places, communities, and forms of knowledge invisible and absent from the systems through which people learn and make sense of the world.

This is particularly relevant for the social sector. What happens to public trust when attention, not accuracy or representation, becomes the primary currency of the digital age?

3. Social change depends on situational intelligence.

We also need to talk about recovering judgment: Once information is visible, the harder task is deciding what it means, where it belongs, and how it should shape action.

AI’s power is its ability to identify patterns across enormous volumes of information. But social change sometimes requires the opposite move. For example, a conservation practitioner deciding how to restore a watershed must understand the particular history of that landscape, the relationships between communities, the local political economy, and forms of ecological knowledge that may never appear in a dataset. Beyond commonalities, it is equally important to stay with the differences.

To this end, Tech4good Community anchors a conservation coalition program that is working with several NGOs to build shared infrastructure for ecological intelligence. They highlight that while interest in AI, analytics, and digital tools is growing rapidly across the social sector, the work they have done with many grassroots conservation organizations demonstrates that organizations today are not just demanding better technology but using that technology in a place-based and locally intelligent manner.

Generalized intelligence needs to be made useful through situational and grounded judgement, with the ability to interpret signals within specific social, ecological, and cultural realities, and to understand when a recommendation should be adapted or ignored. Most importantly, it is important to recognize what is absent from the data as much as what is present.

Learning Capacity to Be Human

This is the paradox of the moment: As intelligence becomes increasingly available on demand, the capacities that may matter are deeply human, not computational. In that sense, the vanishing developmental commons is a story about the environment and experiences we choose to lean into as a society. AI will become more capable. But can we remain intentional about preserving conditions through which people learn to pay attention, make sense of complexity, remain open to wonder, and build coherence between different ways of knowing?

For philanthropy, this may require thinking beyond technology adoption and toward capacity preservation. Supporting institutions, spaces, and practices that cultivate civic trust and value the process as much as the outcome. Perhaps choosing to preserve this inner theater could be one of the most important acts of stewardship we could undertake at this time.

ET | Time to Unlock Silver Abundance

Synopsis: India is still seen as a young country, but its demographic advantage is nearing an end, with the share of working-age population set to decline after 2030 and the elderly population expected to rise sharply. By 2047, India will have around 300 million senior citizens, and within decades could have the world’s largest ageing population.

Do you believe India is a young country? If you quickly answered yes, you would be right. But not for long. The silver economy in India is misunderstood as merely healthcare and nursing homes. Yet it is an $8.7 billion market and growing.

India is at the end phase of its demographic dividend. From 2030 onwards, the ratio of the working age population to the dependent population will start to decline. In 2047, 300 million senior citizens will wave the national flag for India’s 100th anniversary! Twenty years later, we will have the largest population of older adults in the world. It is time to shift our mental model.

This past January in Davos, I was part of a panel discussion on longevity. My co-panellist enthusiastically drew us a vision where science would soon catch up with the ancient human desire for immortality. People would live for 150 years, and then up to 500 years. Like some jellyfish and newts, humans would then crack the code for DNA repair, and live almost indefinitely.

Death is a bug, not a feature, some longevity champions have declared. Being rather old myself, at 66 years, I expressed some concern whether the people around us, especially younger ones, would really like us to live that long. My mother-in-law, Durga Nilekani, passed away peacefully in February at the age of 101. We miss her dearly, but she would always say with a gentle smile, “100 is too much.”

Living longer feels less important than living better. Nevertheless, the race to eternal life might yield many medical miracles on the way for longer healthspans. Already, advances in diagnostics, pharma, genetics and immunotherapy are

delaying death due to disease. What more does the future hold?

How to age well

Recently, in Bengaluru, we convened a crosssector group of scientists, media professionals and social leaders to ask a simple but profound question: what does it take to age well in India? The consensus was clear: ageing is not a problem to be solved, but a societal invitation to reimagine our systems, narratives and institutions.

To do this, we must look at the interplay of Samaaj (Society), Sarkaar (State) and Bazaar (Market). While the state provides infrastructure and policy, and society provides care and connection, it is the market that has the untapped potential to reshape the narrative and possibilities for ageing in India.

Are our markets and media failing our elders? A study of 2,500 Indian advertisements found that older adults are either invisible or depicted as frail, dependent and technophobic nearly half the time. In our films and OTT platforms, they are rarely the complex, vibrant people they are in real life; they are cranky, bedridden, or superhuman.

This is more than just bad marketing; it is a dangerous reinforcement of internalised ageism. When we absorb the story that old age is synonymous with diminishment, we begin to live it. There is a massive economic opportunity to change this version. Can we have more 80-year-olds who love adventure, retired executives who mentor startups, or grandmothers as mental health counsellors?

One of the most startling insights from our Bengaluru meeting was the “40-to-1 mismatch”. For every job opportunity available to those who have stepped away from full-time careers, 40 people are still waiting. This may be a structural failure in our markets. Often, HR departments have younger gatekeepers who filter out older candidates based on outdated assumptions about energy or tech-savviness.

Forward-thinking organisations are beginning to see an “experience dividend”. They frame it as the highest “wisdom per rupee” investment. Older workers bring institutional memory, steadiness and a unique ability to mentor younger teams. At last, some innovation has arrived. Startups like Silver Talkies are creating vibrant social and economic hubs for elders, while platforms like The Elders or WisdomCircle connect retired professionals with companies looking for niche expertise. Even large-scale industries are experimenting with “phased retirement” or advisory roles that keep the “wisdom” in the building while providing the flexibility older professionals desire.

Seniors as consumers

The silver economy in India is misunderstood as merely healthcare and nursing homes. Yet it is an $8.7 billion market and growing. For example, Antara Senior Living reimagines residential spaces as active, socially connected communities. Khyaal offers holistic care, from digital literacy to financial security, tailored for Indian seniors.

These for-profit innovations are essential because they treat older adults as consumers with agency, not recipients of charity. When brands and storytellers see the 225 million people above the age of 55 as a constituency worth speaking to, change will accelerate.

Maybe there is too much of a data gap. Our healthcare system is currently oriented toward sickness—we measure what is broken, not what is thriving. The Bharat Study (Biomarkers for Healthy Ageing) at IISc is a vital step toward establishing India-specific baselines for wellness. We need to understand why Indians age the way they do, factoring in our unique genetics, diet and environment.

Maybe then the market can move from the current fragmented specialist care towards a more integrated model that brings back the “family physician” empowered with 21st century tech.

We cannot talk about growing old in India without speaking about women. Women’s ageing is distinct, marked by physiological and social inflection points like menopause, widowhood and caregiving burdens.

In India, elders contribute $68 billion to the GDP and provide 16 million hours of caregiving annually. Much of this labour is performed by women, yet remains invisible in our economic data. A gender-sensitive approach to ageing is not just a social priority but an economic one.

We are in the early stages of a field in formation. India’s youth bulge will soon become a longevity imperative.

If we get ahead of the curve, we can unlock a new social abundance. Older adults can be happy and productive with a lower environmental footprint.

India’s preparation for the inevitable must start now, in our boardrooms, our media houses and our hearts. In many ways, our society could not fully benefit from the demographic dividend we enjoyed for years! Too many young people were left waiting at the door. We cannot let them down twice.

First Published in The Economic Times 

SSIR | Does Everything in the Social Sector Need to Scale?

by Tanya Kak

For at least two decades, one question has structured much of how philanthropy and the social innovation ecosystem think about change: Can it scale? The question appears in grant applications, accelerator programs, and strategy documents. It makes sense: If a solution works for one community, surely the ethical imperative is to help many more? In a world of vast unmet needs, scale promises efficiency, reach, and speed.

Yet something curious has happened as this logic has spread. Increasingly, promising ideas, organizations, and forms of collective action are all filtered through the same lens, held to the same standard. If it cannot scale, why would it be worth investing in?

This assumption has reshaped the architecture of civil society. It has influenced what kinds of organizations get funded, what kinds of knowledge are valued, and even how social problems themselves are defined. But as geopolitical instability grows, inequality deepens, and social systems fracture in new ways—as the world, in short, ceases to behave like a scalable system—it is time to ask the uncomfortable question: Must all social innovation be designed to scale? Where does “scale thinking” make sense, and where must we re-imagine our way of thinking about progress and innovation?

When Scale Is the Only Default Logic

Scale has become such a powerful organizing idea in philanthropy and development because, at its core, scale thinking is built around growth: the idea that a successful system is one that can reach far more people without a proportional increase in resources. In this framing, the most valuable solutions are those that can expand rapidly while maintaining efficiency. Measurement therefore becomes inseparable from design. If growth is the goal, the ability to demonstrate growth, through metrics such as users reached, households served, hectares restored, or units delivered, becomes central to how value is assessed.

This orientation toward scale has deep roots in development practice. Over the past three decades, governments and development institutions have increasingly searched for replicable models that can be transferred across geographies. Microfinance is one of the most cited examples. What began as locally embedded lending groups evolved into large-scale financial systems serving millions of clients worldwide, supported by standardized metrics such as repayment rates and borrower numbers.

These proof points have guided many of the trends that we now see around scale thinking in the social sector. If an intervention works in one place, the next question quickly becomes whether it can be replicated elsewhere at scale.

Yet researchers studying social innovation suggest that impact spreads through multiple pathways. They distinguish between scaling out (replication across sites), scaling up (influencing policies and institutions), and scaling deep (shifting relationships, cultural norms, and local practices). Other scholars describe scaling wide, where ideas spread through decentralized networks rather than a single expanding organization.

Each pathway has its own role to play. However, operational demands of scale thinking require one to think about some of the building blocks consistently: replicability, standardization, and measurable outputs. The implication is often that complex social processes may need to be simplified into stable models that can travel across contexts, often referred to as “datafication of civil society” by sociologists.

In practice, this can shape which kinds of solutions are prioritized, which organizations receive support, and how social problems themselves come to be defined.

Community organizing, collective stewardship, and cultural shifts rarely translate into easily tracked metrics. For example, take the case of watershed restoration. Building check dams and recharge structures can scale quickly across districts and produce impressive numbers, such as hectares treated and structures built. But whether those gains last often depends on something less visible: local agreements about groundwater use, crop choices in dry years, or who decides when a borewell goes deeper. These decisions are negotiated through trust, local institutions, and leadership within communities. Often harder to count, but they often determine whether resilience endures.

The question, then, is what do we stand to lose if scale thinking becomes the predominant lens of looking at social change? When scalability matters, what kinds of change can it meaningfully carry? What might progress look like if impact were judged not only by how far a solution travels, but also by how well it strengthens the systems around it: the communities, ecosystems, and institutions that allow change to endure?

A World That No Longer Behaves Like a Scalable System

The limits of scale thinking are becoming clearer as the world itself becomes less predictable. Climate volatility, geopolitical fragmentation, and economic shocks are producing systems that behave less like stable machines and more like living ecosystems. In such conditions, solutions designed once and replicated everywhere can quickly reach their limits. What communities need is the capacity to adapt: to learn, reorganize, and respond as circumstances change.

Societies rarely transform through replication alone. Change more often emerges from ecosystems of actors, relationships, and institutions that learn, negotiate, and adapt within specific places. When innovation begins with the realities of people and landscapes, rather than with the assumption that solutions must scale, different possibilities come into view.

For philanthropy, the task may not be to simply support what works at scale, but to cultivate the conditions in which many forms of change can take root. One way to think about this is through navigation. In uncertain waters, ships matter. But ships alone cannot chart the course. They rely on lighthouses that illuminate shifting terrain and bridges that connect otherwise isolated efforts. Civil society increasingly needs this kind of infrastructure: institutions that help actors see the landscape clearly and work together across it. Yet philanthropy still tends to fund the ships (the organizations delivering visible programs) while the quieter systems that help the fleet navigate together remain underbuilt.

What Philanthropy Can Do Differently

  1. Fund the bridges. Philanthropy can invest more deliberately in social infrastructure: convening platforms, shared governance systems, and knowledge networks that allow many actors to collaborate. The Ecological Restoration Alliance, for instance, brings together restoration practitioners, scientists, and community organizations to develop shared protocols and learning systems across landscapes. Rather than scaling a single organization, the alliance strengthens the field’s ability to act collectively.
  2. Back technology that communities steward. Digital platforms can scale while still centering community agency. The local disaster mapping effort in Indonesia, which builds on participatory disaster-mapping approaches pioneered by platforms like PetaBencana, enables citizens to report hazards in real time and contribute to open disaster maps used by communities and governments. The technology works precisely because it is co-designed with users and embedded in local response systems rather than imposed from above.
  3. Invest in the commons. Shared resources such as open data systems, restoration protocols, training networks, and collaborative tools often act as the soil from which innovation grows. One example is CoRE Stack, developed by the Commons Tech Foundation, which provides open, modular digital infrastructure designed specifically for community-led organizations. Rather than building proprietary platforms, CoRE Stack focuses on shared digital public goods, identity systems, registries, consent layers, and governance protocols that many actors can adapt for their own contexts. Funding such commons-based infrastructure enables diverse organizations to collaborate and innovate without each having to build their own technology from scratch.
  4. Build the missing middle. Between grassroots organizations and large global institutions sits a fragile but critical layer of intermediaries: regional networks, knowledge hubs, and field-building organizations that translate ideas across contexts. These actors mentor emerging groups, document learning, and maintain collaboration across ecosystems of practice. For example, the Consortium for Agroecological Transformation exemplifies this approach by supporting networks of farmers, researchers, and grassroots organizations to transition agricultural landscapes toward agroecology.

Looking Beyond Scale

Scale thinking has its place. Some challenges, such as mass vaccination campaigns, disaster early-warning systems, or digital infrastructure for financial inclusion, depend on solutions that can move rapidly across vast populations.

But many of the transformations we now seek from restoring degraded landscapes to rebuilding social trust do not travel in quite the same way. They are shaped slowly on the ground: through experiments that falter before they succeed, through neighbors learning how to respond together in moments of stress, and through local civil society organizations that stay present long after the urgency of a crisis fades. Over time, these everyday negotiations over water, livelihoods, risk, and responsibility begin to form something more durable. Because when crises arrive, systems rarely rise to the occasion overnight; they rise to the level of readiness that has quietly been built in ordinary times, through relationships, trust, and shared norms.

In a world defined by complexity and uncertainty, the task ahead may lie as much in cultivating these enabling conditions as in expanding solutions themselves—strengthening the lighthouses and bridges that help the whole fleet find its way.

First Published in the SSIR 

Alliance Mag | Saving citizenship

Samaaj, Sarkaar, Bazaar: Three Hindi words and a simple theory to stabilise our civic equilibrium

Inevitably perhaps, the world is churning. As this special feature makes clear, fears around declining democracy, failing institutions, and accelerating climate risk abound, and at first glance there are no easy answers. That said, after three decades working in the philanthropic sector, I believe there are pathways forward.

For those unfamiliar with philanthropic work, it is grounded in the Indian context, and my focus has long been on developing a unified theory that describes interactions between three pillars of contemporary humanity. Taken from the Hindi, these pillars are,
Samaaj (Society), Sarkaar (State), and Bazaar (Markets), and I propose that healthy democracies need a strong, active samaaj, or civil society, to balance and guide the sarkaar and bazaar towards collective action and public good.

In this sense, I believe that samaaj has always been our foundation, and states and markets were created to help society scale more effectively and equitably. Importantly, this model depends on states and markets remaining accountable to society, and this is where I
see our contemporary equilibrium failing.

The role of citizens

Reflecting on this, and attempting to rectify the pattern in practice, is something I have since dedicated my time to. Through various philanthropic portfolios, including Access to Justice, Gender, Climate and Environment, we try to empower moral leadership to take on complex challenges, and we partner with both governments and corporations to ensure holistic engagement.

As a result, we’ve seen that when philanthropy supports good ideas, individuals, and institutions with trust and patience, it inspires citizens to exercise their civic muscle for societal missions— and we find these align the incentives of samaaj, sarkaar, and bazaar most fully.

Such stories in our sector are, however, increasingly rare, and as a foundation we’ve begin to see the seminal role of society routinely undermined by all-too-powerful states and markets. We, the people, seem to be market consumers or subjects of the state first, and citizens second, and I find this deeply troubling.

For me, this is the primary reason for the decline of civic institutions we are witnessing, because good governance is something that cannot be consumed, but must be co-created. To that end, just as healthy markets are not a given and must be regulated, so I believe citizenship is not an inborn virtue, but must be cultivated, and that is the task ahead.

Restoring the balance

Philanthropy can play a supporting but bold role to restore this balance. To do this effectively, it must be aware of its own distorting power and be prepared to take the role of scaffolding, not architect.

By doing so, it can help imagine the institutions needed to manage new problems; enable leadership building at every region, age, and level; and can quietly support citizen-owned voluntary movements in adaptation against disasters and economic disruption. It
can help restore the primacy of ‘Samaaj’.

Looking to the future, in my country, India, the social sector faces increasingly strict government regulation while a generation of enlightened social leaders, continue to age. Philanthropy is expanding, yes, but not at the rate needed to drive innovation at scale, yet new philanthropists free from the burdens of legacy can bring much-needed transformation.

Here, new wealth is already exploring solutions in areas including energy transition, AI for education and agriculture, urban design, and more, and importantly, Indian philanthropy is also looking outward, globally, to exchange emerging ideas in a world where power may be shifting from the axes of the past century. This gives me hope, and this hope becomes my new religion. Perhaps it is the only religion that can unite rather than divide humanity and spark the energy needed to dispel inertia. In times like these, hope can be the societal fuel to lift us past the headwinds to come.

The future is unwritten.

First Published in The Allaince Magazine 

SSIR | Climate Adaptation Means Building Social Infrastructure

By Tanya Kak, Portfolio Lead – Climate & Environment 

Picture a mangrove at low tide, its roots holding the shoreline together, sifting silt, breaking waves, and making a home for life that most of us will never see. From a distance, it reads as one green band on the horizon; up close, it is an unruly architecture of roots and relationships, constantly adjusting, failing, and regrowing.

In this moment of cascading climate shocks, adaptation looks more like a mangrove than a sea wall built out of concrete: nurturing the capacities, ties, and institutions that allow people and places to bend without breaking. And while communities have always been adapting, adaptation has finally taken center stage in climate politics and philanthropy, in COP communiqués and high‑level dialogues, in the Adaptation Gap Report, and in the rise of dedicated adaptation and resilience funds. Adaptation finance has grown to an estimated $60–70 billion annually, and overall climate flows climb into the trillions, but developing countries will still need well over $300 billion a year for adaptation by the mid‑2030s. Goals to double adaptation finance by 2025 have already slipped out of reach, even as losses mount and the costs of delay increase.

Hazards are accelerating faster than our ability to rearrange exposure and build capacity. And the language of adaptation finance can feel weightless compared to the lived realities that already shape people’s days: who walks further for water, who can afford to stay indoors during a heatwave, who has the savings or networks to recover after a flood. Does adaptation risk becoming a new label for old habits? How can we prevent it from becoming just a category in a portfolio, a pillar in a theory of change, and a theme for convenings?

In short, what would it mean to use the lived fabric of adaptation to reorient strategy for those working at the intersection of climate, development, and social change? What are the social conditions that make some households absorb climate shocks while others break under their weight?

Are you enjoying this article? Read more like this, plus SSIR’s full archive of content, when you subscribe.

Adaptation comes down to one deceptively simple idea: climate risk is not just about the hazard, it’s about who is exposed to it and what capacities they can draw upon in responding to it. In this sense, there are four interlocking categories of adaptation required:

  1. Hazards: heatwaves, floods, cyclones, drought, sea-level rise, and so on.
  2. Exposure: where people and assets sit in relation to those hazards.
  3. Capacity: the financial, social, institutional, and service systems that help people respond to their exposure to risk.
  4. Institutions and rules: land rights, planning norms, governance, and budgets that shape all three.

For example, a week of extreme heat creates entirely different realities depending on how these categories overlap. In a city where outdoor workers labor in unshaded streets during a heatwave (hazard), informal homes trap heat (exposure), overstretched clinics struggle (capacity), while Heat Action Plans (HAPs) represent a policy response (“Institutions and Rules”): in cities with better shade, labor protections, early warnings, and primary health services, the same hazard event will be far less deadly.

The core proposition, then, is that adaptation is less about shrinking the hazard map than redrawing the exposure and capacity maps: moving people and assets out of harm’s way where possible, and thickening the buffers that absorb shocks where that is not possible. Once the problem is seen this way, the supposed trade‑off between “development” and “climate” begins to dissolve. Safe housing, decent work, clean water, and inclusive governance are simultaneously development gains and adaptation investments.

At Rohini Nilekani Philanthropies, the key learning questions are: First, how do we see and act on risk as a function of exposure and capacity, not just hazard? Second, how do we move from reactive coping (selling assets, withdrawing children from school, migrating under duress) to proactive, collective adaptation? Third, how do we strengthen social, ecological, and institutional systems so that adaptation becomes muscle memory, part of how societies function, rather than a string of standalone projects?

Beneath the generic headlines, recent research on adaptation and vulnerability throws up some counterintuitive, even uncomfortable insights that push us to ask hard questions about resilience and adaptation:

1. Shelter doesn’t mean “safety.”

Heat policy often imagines danger as something you step out into: sun‑baked streets, work sites, agricultural fields. Yet low‑income tin‑roof or poorly ventilated housing across South Asia and African cities often show indoor temperatures regularly exceeding already extreme outdoor heat, especially at night. For older adults, children, people with chronic illness, and women whose work and care roles keep them at home, “taking shelter” can mean living inside a slow oven, rather than escaping one.

Are adaptation strategies designed around actual exposure patterns, or around assumptions that only make sense if you already have a cool, safe home to retreat to?

2. “Coping” can undermine resilience.

Households don’t respond passively to floods, droughts, or heat, but by doing everything they can: borrowing at high interest, selling livestock or tools, reducing meals, moving children out of school, or sending one family member on risky migration. Research on climate shocks and poverty shows, however, that survival under constraint can often erode future earning power, health, and bargaining strength. This means that, in aggregate, what can be misread as “adaptive capacity,” is actually people trading away long‑term security to get through the season.

When we celebrate resilience, are we recognizing people’s agency or overlooking the structural conditions that leave them with only harmful forms of adaptation available?

3. Maladaption

Classic adaptation responses (sea walls, embankments, air conditioning, irrigation canals) can reduce immediate exposure while creating new dependencies and blind spots. Hard coastal defenses, for example, can undermine mangrove ecosystems that would otherwise provide flexible protection, while energy‑intensive cooling strategies can entrench fossil‑heavy grids.

There is a growing literature on “maladaptation,” interventions that only shift risk in time by postponing problems or space, protecting one area while increasing risk elsewhere. The critical question, therefore, is not simply whether infrastructure reduces losses in one place or time but who, elsewhere or later, must live with the new risks it creates?

Adaptation as Social Infrastructure

Adaptation is not a catalog of climate fixes; it’s a social project about housing, labor, debt, care, and voice. It’s about who has room to choose how they adapt, and who is adapting because there was never really a choice at all. As a result, the most durable forms of adaptation often look less like projects and more like infrastructures of relationship and practice that hold under pressure, or social infrastructure: the networks, norms, and institutions that determine whether people face climate shocks alone or together.

Broadly speaking, there are three categories of social infrastructure:

  1. Relational: self‑help groups, cooperatives, neighborhood committees, migrant associations, and informal mutual aid systems. These structures carry information, coordinate evacuations, pool savings, and make it possible to absorb and share risk. 

    For example, through its “mycelium” approach, Asar, a network weaver in India, builds networks across local governments, civil society, communities, and experts. One of their initiatives, Conference of Panchayats (CoP), brings together village panchayats, community-based organizations, SHGs and local governments. In Jharkhand and Maharashtra, CoPs have convened hundreds of Gram Panchayat representatives and community leaders to share lived climate risk, local solutions, and jointly plan adaptation strategies.

  2. Cognitive and cultural: local knowledge of landscapes, seasonal patterns, safe routes, and repair skills; shared stories about what has worked in past crises; norms around reciprocity and care. This is the tacit “software” that allows communities to improvise effectively. 

    For example, in the hills of the Nilgiris in India, the Keystone Foundation has for decades worked as a custodian of Indigenous knowledge systems. Through its People & Nature Collectives program, Keystone archives oral histories, ecological memory, traditional land-use practices, foraging knowledge, food cultures, and seasonal calendars—preserving “community intelligence” that otherwise risks vanishing.

  3. Institutional: local governments, frontline bureaucracies, public health and education systems, and civic spaces that are capable of listening, deciding, and acting under uncertainty. Their behavior in a crisis often matters as much as physical defenses. 

    For example, Jan Sahas (India) works at the intersection of labor rights, migration governance, and social protection— all critical levers in climate-affected regions where heat stress and climate-linked precarity are reshaping labor markets. Through secure mobility corridors, legal aid, and worker-protection systems for millions of migrant and informal workers, Jan Sahas strengthens the very institutions that determine whether workers can adapt without slipping deeper into vulnerability.

When these infrastructures are thick and healthy, communities can adapt in ways that are more equitable, anticipatory, and sustainable. When they are thin or frayed, even well‑designed technical interventions struggle to land. A flood barrier is only as useful as the governance that decides who can live behind it, the warning systems that signal when it might fail, and the social networks that determine who is helped first.

Treating adaptation as a single new funding silo misses the point, because social infrastructure is as varied as human society. The central question is not “how many adaptation projects are in the portfolio?” but “how strong is the social infrastructure that will carry people through the next decade of shocks?”

A Three‑Dimensional Shift

If adaptation is to live up to its current billing, we must think along three dimensions.

1. Political, not just technical.
Resilience is a political question about representation and control, not a neutral outcome of technology deployment. Adaptation is often framed as an engineering problem: build sea walls, launch early warning systems, pilot drought‑tolerant crops. These efforts matter, but they remain brittle if divorced from power. Real adaptation demands that those most affected are not merely consulted but centered in decision‑making.

2. Development protection, not a separate track.
For many communities, adaptation is synonymous with preserving hard‑won development gains. When rains fail, or floods surge, schools close, health systems buckle, food prices spike, and housing becomes precarious. Well‑designed adaptation investments function as a form of development insurance: they keep children in school, water systems running, clinics open, and families housed despite climate shocks. Treating adaptation and development as separate silos ignores this interdependence. It also risks double-counting: labelling essential social spending as “climate” without changing its design to address risk over time.

3. Long‑term, not project‑bounded.
True resilience is not built in two‑year cycles with pilot‑phase budgets and pre‑set exit strategies. Institutions that learn, infrastructure that is maintained, and communities that trust the systems around them all take time to grow. Short grants and discrete projects can spark innovation, but they rarely sustain it. Adaptation requires persistent, patient investment: in planning and maintenance, in local leadership, in the capacity to monitor, evaluate, and iterate under changing conditions.

Adaptation Ambitions: Reimagined

Taken together, these three shifts suggest that the heart of adaptation lies less in the novelty of interventions and more in the durability and fairness of the systems in which they are embedded.

The current surge of interest in adaptation offers a rare chance to reset the field’s ambitions. Rather than aspiring to “climate‑proof” societies (an impossibility in a world already transformed), it invites a more grounded goal: to cultivate social infrastructures that allow people to navigate uncertainty with agency, solidarity, and some measure of security.

This is quieter than many slogans, but also more radical. It asks for institutions that are willing to share power, not just funds; for metrics that can hold complexity, not just count outputs; and for strategies that honor the improvisations communities are already making, instead of treating them as footnotes to formal plans.

First Published in Stanford Social Innovation Review 

ET | Why we should disconnect from digital devices and reconnect with Mother Nature

Almost every morning, from November to February, we can expect magic to happen outside our bedroom window in Koramangala, a leafy suburb in Bengaluru. A male Asian paradise flycatcher, with twin white ribbons in his tail, alights on the lagerstroemia tree branch, chirps out its arrival, and swings into a preening routine. Occasionally diving delicately and deftly into the pool beyond, he then returns to clean his feathers, black head ducking and turning, feathers shivering and satin tail dancing. This bird can lure the husband away from his desk, no matter how urgent the email. Yes, magic does manifest in this season.

Such enchantment might be the gateway to a new reconnect. People want to disconnect from digital devices, but we need something to connect back to. We are so connected to our machines and so disconnected from our people.

A few generations ago, most of our ancestors were in professions relating to the soil, or to the trade of things grown in the soil. Their senses had to be sharp to assess the real world around them — the hiss of a snake, the sawing of a leopard, the screech of a raptor. If you didn’t sense these, you could lose crops, or cattle or worse. You had to know how the wind turns, or the tide; how the rain falls, or if the earth would be scorched.

Few readers would be able to tune in to nature any more. Our ancient instincts are dulled, though other skills have been honed. So, if we want to journey back to the future, to recover what we have lost, we need to start like babies.

Escape into Nature
We need to see everything with fresh eyes. Personally, I started on birding when I was in a postpartum low. Pacing the terrace of my parent’s Pune house in the mornings, to get some exercise and fresh air, while the babies were with the grandparents, I inadvertently started noticing splashes of colour flitting between the trees. The colours had names like coppersmith barbet and purple-rumped sunbird and ashy prinia.

Slowly but surely, the birds whistled and screeched and chirped me out of my shrunken self into the dense tree canopy below and the vast sky above. Soaring Brahminy kites and shikras felt like a stirring hope, the raucous parakeets heralded a bustle outside my own mental life, and I started to emerge again.

Ihave never forgotten that lesson, and to this day, I escape into nature, wherever I can find it, to lose myself, to find myself, to recalibrate, to re-energise, and to feel free. To reconnect. Everyone can do it. It doesn’t cost anything. In most places across the country, if you are still for 10 minutes, you might catch some bird sound or the other. In India, so far, nature is everywhere.

Being, just being in nature is shown to restore attention, and can put you in a flow, beyond time, beyond weariness.

Little by little, observing nonhuman forms of life, we can sharpen our eyesight, hearing, sense of smell. Birdwatchers are known to even feel birds behind their backs. Such are the many possibilities outside the realms of our discovered lives, our rinse and repeat routines. Who knows how such skills might help us in the uncertain times ahead?

“One touch of nature makes the whole world kin,” said William Shakespeare.

Often misquoted, the bard warns us through this line spoken by Ulysses that humans are ever attracted to the new, the shining object, forgetting the gold in the old, and in that we are the same, it is our common failing, our nature. Yet, read another way, it could easily mean that it is only by immersing in nature, in the wild, that we sense our deepest interdependencies, our complex connections. In 2026, read either way, it seems like wise counsel. Let’s reconnect to magic!

First published in The Economic Times 

The Indian Express | We Need a Mental Health Movement Rooted in Community

When we help others, we help ourselves. It is a win-win described for samaaj by good science

Just five minutes a day of contemplative practices to improve mindfulness, connection, insight and purpose have been scientifically proven to create positive changes in the brain’s chemistry. Compassion training has demonstrably shown reduced implicit bias towards people you knowingly or unknowingly dislike. Meditating monks have zero anticipatory anxiety and a quick recovery from an experiment of planned exposure to extreme heat. Pregnant women who practise awareness in the second trimester can give their children a health advantage that lasts for years.

These and other scientific data were included in a talk by neuroscientist Richard Davidson, who has spent years studying the brains of Buddhist monks. His advice to Indians? You have rituals and practices already deeply embedded in your society that you can conserve and enhance in order to flourish. Davidson was speaking at the second edition of the National Mental Health Festival, called Manotsava (a celebration of the mind) in Bengaluru, co-created by the National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences, the National Centre for Biological Sciences and my foundation, Rohini Nilekani Philanthropies. There is no other festival like this, at this scale, anywhere in the world, though there is an urgent need to have one in every state in India, if not every district.

According to the pre-pandemic National Mental Health Survey 2015–16, 150 million people in India need mental health interventions, yet the treatment gap ranges between 70 per cent and 92 per cent, with the gap for common mental disorders that are easily prevented or treated remaining at 85 per cent. The goal of Manotsava is to flip the existing model and associate mental health with wellness, not just disease, and bring science and society closer. Manotsava was free and open to the public, catering to people of all ages, from young children to senior citizens. The curation was selected from more than 700 responses to a request for proposals and had extremely diverse offerings. There was a solid science track, including a stall of the Centre for Brain and Mind with brain models, genetic testing and other methodologies to discover mental illness. There were sessions on digital distractions and addictions, gender discrimination and problems with marital intimacy, workplace stress, parenting, and ageing. Alongside a development track for NGOs, there was a philanthropy lunch to invite investment in this neglected area of public health.

One workshop titled “Living after the storm: A toolkit for adult survivors of sexual abuse” was deluged by people who had not found any such safe space before. There were psychiatrists and counsellors to answer questions and help people who might get triggered by discussions that evoke painful memories. Kaz De Jong, of Doctors Without Borders, a network of volunteers present in some of the most difficult areas of the world, spoke of trauma and conflict, of people who had lost their entire families in regional wars, had witnessed daily disease and suffering, and yet were able to leave their loss behind and focus on helping other people. In any situation, he said, there are always some things that still work, and hope is a powerful antidote to despair and helplessness. The government’s helpline Tele MANAS has received 25 lakh calls since its inception in 2022, and nearly 40,000 of those were for suicidal thoughts. The overwhelming response from the general public surfaced a deep latent demand to understand issues of mental health and wellness.

One of the most potent sessions was called “Deewanagi: My Tryst with Madness”, a title chosen by the panellists. Three people openly and bravely shared their personal journey with bipolar disorder and schizophrenia. All of them thanked their doctors, but expressed even greater gratitude to family and friends. Mental health discourse and practice currently focus more on intra-psychic aspects, and not enough on relational methods and the importance of family and community. Most of the work is between the patient and the doctor. Yet there is increasing evidence to show that when a whole community finds the inner resources to help a troubled mind in its midst, it develops its own resilience and a pathway to overall well-being. When we help others, we help ourselves.

It is a win-win described for samaaj by good science. That should be reason enough for Indian philanthropy to help create many more Manotsavas around the country.

The Indian Express